"Is SCS a Last Resort?" — An Option to Weigh Before Surgery
Surgery or putting up with the pain aren't the only two choices. There is also SCS, a treatment you can undo if it doesn't suit you.
This column is general information. The right treatment depends on your symptoms, so talk with your doctor.
"At my last hospital they recommended an operation to fuse the bones in my lower back. But at my age, a big operation scares me."
I hear this a lot in my clinic. Many people believe they have two choices: have surgery, or keep putting up with the pain.
In Week 22 I said briefly that SCS (spinal cord stimulation) is not a last resort. This week I'll pick up from there and explain why I want you to know about SCS before you decide on surgery.
Surgery and putting up with the pain aren't the only paths.
When Surgery Should Come First
- Your legs feel weak
- You have trouble urinating or moving your bowels, or you have leakage
If you have symptoms like these, surgery should be considered first. Talk to your doctor without delay.
And if your symptoms would improve with decompression, the surgery that widens the narrowed space around the nerves, I still believe surgery is the best choice.
When the Fusion Gets Longer
Fusion surgery, which joins vertebrae together with metal implants, is a somewhat different story, especially when several levels need to be fused.
A fused section of the spine no longer moves. The vertebrae next to it take on that extra work, and over the years they can wear out and need another operation. The longer the fusion, the more it gradually narrows both your body's freedom of movement and your future treatment options.
So when only one level needs fusing, I often recommend the fusion. When it looks as though two or three levels will be needed, I think SCS is worth considering first. That view comes from my own clinical experience.
A Treatment You Can Undo
In SCS, a thin electrode is placed in your back, and electrical signals ease the pain signals. It is not an operation that reshapes your body by cutting away or fusing bone.
- If you're unsure, you can try it before the permanent implant to see how it works for you. This is called a trial.
- Even after the permanent treatment has started, if you feel it doesn't suit you, the device can be removed completely. Removal is a short operation under local anesthesia.
- Once it's removed, it doesn't get in the way of later tests or surgery.
Before you have an operation that can't be undone, know that there is also a treatment you can undo if it doesn't suit you. I believe choosing with that in mind leads to fewer regrets.
The Limits of SCS
- It does not work for everyone.
- It may be somewhat less effective for numbness than for pain. That said, I have seen patients whose numbness went away after SCS.
- There are certain restrictions on MRI scans.
- The goal is not to bring pain down to zero but to keep pain from running your life.
Summary
- If your legs are getting weaker, or you have bladder or bowel trouble, surgery comes first.
- For stenosis that improves with decompression, surgery is the best choice.
- If the main problem is pain and the fusion looks likely to cover a long stretch of spine, or if pain remains after surgery, consider SCS as an option before you decide.
- SCS doesn't reshape your spine, and it can be undone.
At your next appointment, ask just one question: "Would SCS be right for me?"